In my experience everything 37signals cranks out is over rated. I’m not sure why they get the positive press, and adoption rate they do.
I’m going to keep a running list of stuff that drives me nuts about it:
- You only received notifications when something is created, if something is edited you have no way of knowing
- To clear up what I am talking about here. I know that you can explicitly include when you edit a message. However, what I would like to see is basecamp remember who was originally notified, and make them the default for notifications for that message.
- Also, what would be nice, is what a message is edited, have it tell you what changed
- You CANNOT reply to notifications. You are forced to click on the link in the message, and wait the average 4 second load time for the page.
- This feature has not been added because a lot of people don’t want it. However, based on my discussions with people both on and offline, a lot of people DO want it. So, why isn’t it a configurable option?
- Notifications don’t tell you what files are attached to a message, just that there might be some random number
- Links in messages become plain text in notifications, so you have no way of knowing that there are even links in the message
- It is SLOW, seriously slow. Practically unusably slow.
- Notifications only have the site name in them, no client or project information so you cannot easily sort through them quickly. You have to click on each message and hunt down contextual information.
- The notification subjects are so abstract that most email clients cannot thread them.
If I have made an error, and you know of a way of correcting any of the above mentioned behavior please let me know!
Recent Comments